Home > Macro/Monetary Theory > A Bit of Finance

A Bit of Finance

Here is a concrete way in which the Austrians are confused.  They think when the economy collapses, that the stock market will go down and gold and silver will go up.  This is because they think the threat to the economy is hyperinflation.  When you see those gold commercials on TV they always talk about using gold to diversify your portfolio.  I get the feeling most people don’t really know what this means because I once saw Shepard Smith going off about how gold is not safe as though he thought that people think that gold is just inherently safer than other investments.  But that’s not the point.  Traditionally, gold is a hedge.  To put it simply, this means that gold goes up when other things, like the stock market, go down and vice versa.  Because of this if you hold both gold and stocks then you are less likely to suffer a large loss because large drops in one asset are usually offset by large gains in the other.

So if you buy into this logic, and you think a stock market crash is coming, it makes sense to invest in gold, not only as a hedge, but as a bet against the stock market.  But if you have been following the markets on a more-or-less daily basis as I have, then you may have noticed that these two things no longer move in opposite directions.  For some time (like 6 months to a year) when the stock market has gone up gold has gone up and when the stock market has gone down gold has gone down.  Unfortunately this is only a casual observation I don’t have data to show you but look into it, it’s true.

So why is this happening?  Gold and stocks are different in that they appeal to opposite attitudes about the real economy.  When people are optimistic about the real economy they buy stocks because they expect them to grow rapidly in real value.  When they are pessimistic, they buy gold because they figure gold won’t completely evaporate in real value like stocks are prone to do.  So they tend to move in opposite directions due to real shocks.  But gold and stocks have something in common.  They are both real goods.  Which means they are both subject to monetary shocks in the same way.  When the price level goes up, they both go down.  when the price level goes down they both go up.  So what we are seeing now is a real economy which is fluctuating mainly due to monetary shocks not real shocks.  This means that gold and stocks are no longer hedges for each other.  Inflation helps both but more importantly, deflation–which is what we should be worried about–kills both.  Think about this before you put all your money in gold.

Categories: Macro/Monetary Theory Tags: ,
  1. February 6, 2013 at 11:51 am

    Sharebuilder is an excellent comapny to purchase stocks with if you are opening a DRIP Plan. DRIP’s are seldom talked about because brokers make very little money when they suggest them. Yet, they have proven to be one of the best, if not the best, long-term strategy on Wall Street. They are perfect for small investors, as well as big investors. They are safe and allow you to not care about whether the market is going up or down. However, DRIP Plans are most effective on a long-term basis. If you do not plan on keeping you money in them for atleast 5 years, you might consider other options. Be careful about mutual funds. People will lead you to believe that they are a safe haven. About 75% of them under perform the stock market. All of them have management fees, and some of them have sales loads.There are good mutual funds available, but you really have to look at their track records.Ask your parents for some guidance.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: